When to Use 'This': The Nuances of Precision in English Grammar

Published

when to use

The word "this" is deceptively simple—a two-letter pronoun that anchors sentences in time, space, and meaning. Yet its deployment is far from arbitrary. Misplace it, and a sentence loses its precision; use it correctly, and it becomes the invisible thread tying ideas together. The question of when to use "this" isn’t just about grammar; it’s about intent. Is it pointing to a tangible object, a fleeting moment, or an abstract concept? The answer determines whether your writing feels sharp or muddled.

Consider the difference between "This report is critical" and "That report is critical." The shift from "this" to "that" doesn’t just change distance—it alters perspective. One implies urgency, the other detachment. Linguists and editors agree: the choice between "this" and "that" (or "these" and "those") is a micro-decision with macro consequences. It’s the difference between a sentence that informs and one that commands attention.

Yet even experts stumble. Studies on spoken and written language reveal that native speakers often default to "this" out of habit, even when "that" would convey temporal or emotional distance more accurately. The result? Ambiguity. Clarity, however, isn’t just about avoiding errors—it’s about leveraging "this" as a tool for emphasis, connection, and rhetorical control.

when to use 'this'

The Complete Overview of When to Use "This"

The pronoun "this" serves as a linguistic anchor, grounding statements in immediacy—whether spatial, temporal, or conceptual. Unlike its counterpart "that," which signals removal (distance, past, or abstraction), "this" binds the speaker or writer to the present moment, the here-and-now, or the idea under immediate consideration. Understanding when to use "this" hinges on recognizing three primary dimensions: proximity, temporal relevance, and rhetorical emphasis.

Proximity isn’t just physical. In writing, "this" can refer to the topic sentence of a paragraph, the central argument of an essay, or even the overarching theme of a discussion. For example:

  • "This argument, though controversial, holds merit because..."
    • Here, "this" doesn’t point to a physical object but to the preceding idea, creating a cohesive link. Conversely, "that" would sever the connection, making the sentence feel disjointed. The rule of thumb? If the reference is the immediate focus—whether in time, space, or discourse—"this" is the default choice.

    Yet the line between "this" and "that" blurs in spoken language, where context is fluid. A speaker might say "This meeting is important" while gesturing to a calendar, but if the meeting is in the past, "that" would be grammatically accurate. The ambiguity underscores why when to use "this" is less about rigid rules and more about contextual awareness. Mastery comes from training the ear to detect shifts in reference—whether in a novel, a debate, or a casual conversation.

    Historical Background and Evolution

    The distinction between "this" and "that" traces back to Old English, where demonstrative pronouns evolved to mark not just physical distance but also conceptual hierarchy. By the Middle English period, "this" had solidified as the pronoun of immediacy, while "that" became the marker of removal—both spatially and temporally. Shakespeare’s plays, for instance, frequently exploit this contrast to signal shifts in time or perspective. In Hamlet, the phrase "this above all: to thine own self be true" uses "this" to elevate the advice to a present, urgent command, whereas "that" would imply it’s a distant, theoretical suggestion.

    Table of Contents

    Linguistic scholars note that the modern usage of "this" in abstract contexts (e.g., "this idea is flawed") reflects a broader trend in English: the blurring of physical and metaphorical space. What began as a spatial demonstrative now functions as a discursive one, tying sentences together in ways that "that" cannot. This evolution mirrors how language adapts to cognitive needs—prioritizing coherence over literal distance. The result? A word that does double duty: as a pointer to objects and as a stitcher of arguments.

    The 20th century saw further refinement, particularly in technical and academic writing, where "this" became a staple for introducing new topics or reinforcing continuity. A research paper might open with "This study examines..." to signal the beginning of a focused discussion, while "that study, however, found..." would reference prior work. The contrast isn’t just grammatical; it’s structural, reinforcing the hierarchy of information.

    Core Mechanisms: How It Works

    At its core, "this" functions as a deictic marker—a term from linguistics for words that rely on context for meaning. Its power lies in its ability to create a shared frame of reference between speaker and audience. When someone says "this is delicious," the listener immediately associates "this" with the food in front of them. Remove the context, and the sentence collapses into nonsense. This dependency on context is why when to use "this" is so critical in writing: without visual or auditory cues, the reader must infer the reference from the surrounding text.

    The mechanism involves three layers:
    1. Anaphora: "This" often refers back to a noun or idea introduced earlier in the text. For example:

  • "The climate crisis is accelerating. This demands immediate action."
    • Here, "this" replaces "the climate crisis" without repetition, maintaining flow.
    2. Cataphora: Less common but equally precise, "this" can also point forward to an upcoming idea:
  • "This solution—though unconventional—will be explored in the next section."
    • The reader’s anticipation is primed by "this," creating suspense.
    3. Emphatic Focus: "This" can isolate a single element for emphasis, as in:
  • "I like many things about this city, but this park is my favorite."
    • The repetition of "this" narrows the focus to the park, overriding other possibilities.

    The key to deploying "this" effectively is cohesion. Every use should either:

  • Connect the current idea to what came before (anaphoric),
  • Preview what’s to come (cataphoric), or
  • Highlight a specific detail amid competing information (emphatic).
    • Fail to align "this" with one of these functions, and the sentence risks becoming a grammatical orphan—detached from its context.

    Key Benefits and Crucial Impact

    The strategic use of "this" is a cornerstone of clear communication. It reduces cognitive load by eliminating ambiguity, ensuring the reader or listener doesn’t pause to reconstruct meaning. In technical fields like law or medicine, where precision is non-negotiable, "this" and "that" serve as navigational tools, guiding the audience through complex arguments. A poorly worded contract might say "the following terms are binding," but a precise one would use "these terms" (for proximity) or "those terms" (for distance), leaving no room for misinterpretation.

    Beyond clarity, "this" enhances rhetorical control. Politicians, marketers, and storytellers exploit its immediacy to create urgency or intimacy. A campaign slogan like "This is your moment" leverages "this" to collapse time and space, making the call to action feel inescapable. Conversely, "that was your moment" would sound like a reproach, distancing the audience from the present.

    The psychological impact is measurable. Studies in cognitive linguistics show that demonstratives like "this" activate the brain’s mirror neuron system, prompting listeners to "experience" the referent as if it were physically present. This is why "this" works so well in persuasive writing—it doesn’t just describe; it invites participation.

    > "Language is a village street where the houses are built of words." — John Ruskin > Yet even the most architecturally sound street can feel disjointed if the demonstratives—those humble signposts—are misplaced. "This" is the streetlight that illuminates the path forward, while "that" is the distant glow of what’s been left behind.

    Major Advantages

    • Eliminates Ambiguity: "This report" (current focus) vs. "that report" (past or secondary) ensures the reader knows exactly what’s being referenced, preventing misdirection.
    • Enhances Flow: By replacing nouns with "this," writers create smoother transitions, reducing the need for awkward phrasing like "the aforementioned idea."
    • Creates Emphasis: Repetition of "this" (e.g., "this is the point; this is why it matters") draws attention to critical ideas, reinforcing their importance.
    • Signals Temporal Proximity: In narratives, "this" anchors the present moment, while "that" shifts to the past, helping readers track time without explicit markers like "then" or "now."
    • Strengthens Rhetorical Impact: "This" in headlines or calls-to-action ("This changes everything") feels more immediate and compelling than "that" or "it."

    when to use 'this' - Ilustrasi 2

    Comparative Analysis

    Usage Context When to Use "This"
    Spatial Reference Use "this" for nearby objects/ideas. Example: "Pass me this pen, not that one."
    Temporal Reference Use "this" for present or imminent events. Example: "This meeting is today; that one was last week."
    Discursive Cohesion Use "this" to link to the immediate topic. Example: "This argument relies on data from Chapter 3."
    Emphatic Focus Use "this" to isolate a key detail. Example: "Of all the options, this one stands out."
    As language evolves, so does the role of "this." In digital communication, where screens replace physical space, "this" is adapting to new contexts. Social media platforms, for instance, often use "this" in captions to create a sense of immediacy—"This post is for the dreamers"—even though the "here" is virtual. Meanwhile, AI-driven writing tools are beginning to analyze demonstrative usage for tone and clarity, flagging instances where "this" might be overused or misplaced.

    The future may also see a greater emphasis on multimodal demonstratives, where "this" isn’t just textual but tied to interactive elements (e.g., "Click this button"). As augmented reality becomes mainstream, "this" could gain new dimensions, pointing to virtual objects in ways that defy traditional spatial logic. One thing is certain: the word’s ability to bridge gaps—between speaker and listener, past and present, idea and action—will only grow in value.

    when to use 'this' - Ilustrasi 3

    Conclusion

    The question of when to use "this" is less about memorizing rules and more about developing an ear for language’s rhythm. It’s the difference between a sentence that exists and one that resonates. Whether you’re drafting a legal document, crafting a novel, or debating a friend, the choice between "this" and "that" is a decision with weight. It’s the linguistic equivalent of a well-placed period: seemingly small, but capable of altering the entire meaning.

    Ultimately, "this" is a tool of connection. It doesn’t just point—it invites the audience into the conversation. Use it wisely, and every sentence becomes a bridge; use it carelessly, and the meaning drifts away like a half-remembered dream.

    Comprehensive FAQs

    Q: Can "this" ever refer to something in the past?

    A: Rarely, but it can in specific contexts where the past is being treated as the "immediate frame of reference." For example, in a historical narrative: "This battle in 1944 turned the tide of the war." Here, "this" refers to a past event framed as the current focus of the discussion. However, "that battle" would be more natural in most cases.

    Q: Is there a difference between "this" and "it" in terms of emphasis?

    A: Yes. "This" is demonstrative—it points and emphasizes by highlighting proximity or relevance. "It" is generic and often replaces a noun without emphasis. Compare: "This solution is brilliant" (emphatic) vs. "It is brilliant" (neutral). "This" feels more direct and engaging.

    Q: How do I decide between "this" and "these" for plural references?

    A: The rule is simple: "this" is singular, "these" is plural. Use "these" for multiple nearby items ("These files need reviewing") and "this" for a single one ("This file is corrupted"). The distinction is purely grammatical, not contextual.

    Q: Can "this" be used in formal writing, or is it too casual?

    A: "This" is perfectly acceptable in formal writing—when used correctly. It’s essential in academic papers for introducing topics ("This study examines...") or linking ideas ("This conclusion follows from the data"). The key is avoiding overuse; balance it with "that" for variety.

    Q: What’s the most common mistake people make with "this"?

    A: The most frequent error is using "this" when "that" would better convey temporal or emotional distance. For example, saying "This decision was made yesterday" sounds awkward because "this" implies present relevance. The fix? "That decision" (past) or "This decision today" (if emphasizing immediacy).

    Q: How can I improve my use of "this" in speaking?

    A: Practice active listening. Notice how native speakers use "this" in conversations—often to signal new topics, emphasize points, or correct misunderstandings. Record yourself speaking and analyze where "this" feels forced. Also, read aloud from well-written texts, pausing to identify "this" references and their purpose.

    Leave a Comment

    Comments are moderated before appearing. The data you submit is processed according to the Privacy Policy of Sac.